Podcast: Avoiding Unexpected Bills When Returning Your Lease Car

In our latest podcast, we discuss returning a lease car and offer some advice to take some of the stress out of the process.

Whether you’re an individual returning your first lease car or a fleet manager handling hundreds of vehicles, this guide is packed with practical tips.

Have you ever had an unexpected bill that you've ended up having to pay?

Returning a lease car should be straightforward, but for many drivers it’s a moment of real anxiety. Small scuffs, dents, or missing items can quickly translate into unexpected bills from the lease company. The good news is that with a little knowledge and preparation, you can avoid most of these charges — and the stress that comes with them.

Why the Worry?

Most drivers simply don’t know where they stand. Is that scuff on the bumper “fair wear and tear” or will it result in a hefty bill? Should you repair a wheel scratch before handing the car back? And what if you miss something the inspector spots?

This uncertainty leads many people to either spend money on unnecessary repairs or take their chances and end up paying more than they needed to.

Cheap Repairs: A False Economy

It’s tempting to use a mobile smart repair technician for quick, cheap fixes. But lease companies have strict standards: repairs must show no obvious signs of being done, and the guarantee must be transferable. A poor job can actually increase your risk of charges, as the lease company may reject it and bill you again.

Solution: If you’re repairing damage, ensure it’s done to a proper standard, with a transferable guarantee. Better still, check with your lease company before spending money — in some cases their charges are actually cheaper than arranging repairs yourself.

What Counts as Fair Wear and Tear?

In the UK, most lease companies follow the BVRLA fair wear and tear guidelines. For example:

• Small dents under 10mm (and only a couple per panel) are acceptable.
• Light scuffs on wheels up to 25mm (about an inch) may be allowed.
• Larger scratches, cracks, or multiple marks are not.

Solution: Ask your lease company for their written guidelines or a matrix of charges. Many will provide photos and set prices so you know exactly what to expect.

The Most Common (and Costly) Charges

Some of the biggest bills aren’t from dents or scratches at all. The most common recharges include:

• Missing spare key – often hundreds of pounds, sometimes close to a thousand.
• Lost locking wheel nut, parcel shelf or service book.
• Tyres – especially if they’re the wrong brand or specification.
• Unstamped service history.

Solution: Before returning your car, double-check all accessories are present and correct, and make sure your servicing is fully documented.

Understanding Thresholds

Lease companies often set a financial threshold for charges. For example, if your damage adds up to less than £500, they may choose not to bill you at all. Go over that threshold, however, and you could be charged for everything.

Solution: If you know about some damage, weigh up whether to repair it or accept the risk. Again, the key is to know the company’s policy.

What Happens on Return

The collection driver is not the final inspector. Your car will usually go to a compound where trained staff assess it under controlled conditions. A couple of weeks later, you’ll receive a bill with photos of any chargeable damage.

Solution: Don’t rely on the collection driver’s opinion. Prepare your car properly and, ideally, arrange an independent pre-return inspection so you know exactly where you stand.

If You Disagree with Charges

If you believe you’ve been billed unfairly, you can appeal. In the UK, the BVRLA offers an arbitration process where an independent inspector assesses the car.

Solution: Keep records. Photos of your car on the day of return can be invaluable if you need to dispute a charge.

---

Final Thoughts

Returning a lease car doesn’t have to be a nerve-wracking experience. The key is to:

1. Know the rules – get the fair wear and tear guidelines from your lease company.
2. Check your car properly – or have it inspected by a professional.
3. Communicate early – ask your lease company about likely charges before you hand the car back.
4. Don’t overlook the basics – keys, documents, tyres, and accessories matter just as much as scratches.

A little preparation can save you hundreds — and a lot of heartache.