It is tempting to just get rid of a car with a water leak. Gary explains why that instinct usually costs more than fixing it -- and what to do if you do decide to sell.
The thought of selling a leaky car crosses most people's minds at some point. Gary's honest answer in this video is: yes, you can -- but it is worth understanding what that decision actually costs before you do. We run a 28-point water leak inspection and give you a full written report so you can make that decision with real information rather than frustration.
The transaction cost nobody mentions
If your car is worth £5,000 and you want to replace it with something similar, you are not spending £5,000 -- you are spending £6,000 to £7,000 once you factor in the transaction. Gary uses a house analogy: moving into the identical house opposite yours might cost you £30,000 just in fees and friction. Cars are the same. Unless you are making a significant upgrade, the money you spend swapping for a like-for-like replacement often exceeds what it would have cost to fix the car you already know.
The karma argument
Gary's other reason for not rushing to sell: what goes around comes around. Advertising a car as having a water leak and letting someone else deal with it is an option, but it is not one he recommends. If you do sell, his advice is to be transparent -- get the leak fixed first, note it in the advert, explain what was done and by whom. A 2012 Ford Focus with a known water leak issue that has been properly repaired by a specialist is a more attractive proposition than one with an unresolved problem. Buyers who know the model will recognise it; buyers who don't will appreciate the honesty.
Fix first, then decide
There is a third option that the current text on most of these pages misses: fix the car, then decide whether to keep it. Once it is repaired and back to how it should be, the urgency goes. You can take your time shopping for a replacement, say no to cars you are not confident about, and wait for the right one -- because you have your own car back in the meantime. And occasionally, once the leak is gone and the car is sorted, the decision to keep it makes itself.
Occasionally it genuinely does make sense not to keep the car. Gary says so plainly. But that conclusion is worth reaching after a proper inspection and a clear report -- not in the middle of a frustrating week with wet carpets.
Share this video